IOWA'S HOME OF CRAFT PEANUT BUTTER. FRESH-HOMEMADE-UNFORGETABLE
NUTMARE
AVAILABLE FOR PICK UP OR DROP OFF WITHIN IOWA
MOST POPULAR ITEM
THE FLAVORS
Nutmare
Original flavor with Blanched Peanuts with the choice of salted or unsalted
Iowa's haunting
Local Iowa honey straight from the honey farms! One of our Deluxe flavors!
The Golden Harvest
One of our Deluxe flavors that uses Acacia honey. It's considered one of the sweetest honeys in the world.
Devil's Fiddle
Our second best-selling flavor. Has a smokey and spicy kick that slowly creeps up on you. Our best-selling deluxe flavor!
Spooky Cookie
One of our premium flavors introducing granola cookies mixed in! You'll want more!
Ghostly Chill
Cooling mint undertones meet rich organic peanuts for a chill that goes straight to the bone. Our second premium flavor!
Batter Splatter
This just keeps selling out. We can't keep up! All organic ingredients making it tastes like real brownie baater!
ORIGIN
From Des Moines with a Dark Twist
Nutmare began with a simple belief: good food should bring people together. What started with a love for peanut butter and jelly grew into a bigger vision—creating fresh, handcrafted products made with simple ingredients and real care. Inspired by the energy of rock and roll, the edge of horror culture, and the hardworking spirit of Iowa, Nutmare was created to offer something different for Des Moines. Today, every jar is made in small batches using quality ingredients, local sourcing whenever possible, and a commitment to keeping unnecessary junk out of our products. While Nutmare currently focuses on handcrafted peanut butter, the vision reaches far beyond the jar. The long-term goal is to build a gathering place for the community—a simple restaurant built around fresh ingredients, homemade bread, homemade jelly, and food made with purpose. More importantly, it will be a place where customers feel welcome, employees feel valued, and the community comes first. Nutmare isn’t just about selling food. It’s about creating something meaningful, supporting local communities, bringing people together, and giving back whenever possible. As the business grows, part of that mission includes supporting causes that matter and helping make a positive impact beyond the walls of the business itself. Every jar sold today helps build that future one step at a time.
Coming Soon!
What do you think is brewing? Comment down below what ideas you think are in play!



