WHY NUTMARE HITS DIFFERENT
NOT ALL PEANUT BUTTER IS CREATED EQUAL. EVERY NUTMARE JAR IS CRAFTED IN SMALL BATCHES WITH REAL INGREDIENTS, BOLD FLAVORS, AND A STORY BEHIND EVERY SPREAD.
🥜 REAL INGREDIENTS
Fresh peanuts, real fruit, local honey, and simple ingredients you can recognize.
👻 SMALL BATCH CRAFTED
Made in small batches for quality and consistency—not mass-produced in giant factories.
🌽 MADE IN IOWA
Proudly handcrafted in Iowa and inspired by the Midwest.
🚫 NO PRESERVATIVES
No unnecessary preservatives. Just real food and real flavor.
Ready to taste the Nightmare?
🎃 unique FLAVORS
From Iowa’s Haunting and Devil’s Fiddle to Vampire’s Kiss and Blackberry Midnight.
❤️ FAMILY OWNED
Every purchase supports a local family business chasing a dream.
THE FLAVORS
Nutmare
Iowa's Haunting
The Origin: Before the monsters, before the madness, there was the original. Nutmare Original was created to prove that simple ingredients can still create something unforgettable. Fresh peanuts, a touch of salt, and nothing to hide behind.
Nutmare Warning: Many customers buy this as a “safe choice.” They usually return for more flavors.
The Origin: I wanted a flavor that represented home. Using locally sourced Iowa honey, I created a peanut butter that captures the sweetness of the Midwest while staying true to Nutmare’s dark roots. It’s proof that even Iowa has a few sweet secrets hiding in the shadows.
Nutmare Warning: Strange sightings of empty jars have been reported throughout Iowa.
8oz: $12.99
16oz: $16.99
8oz: $13.99
16oz: $17.99
The Golden Harvest
Devil's Fiddle
The Origin: I wanted to create a peanut butter that felt rich, smooth, and a little special. After discovering acacia honey—one of the sweetest honeys in the world—I knew it deserved its own flavor. Golden Harvest combines fresh peanuts and golden honey into a jar worthy of a king’s table.
Nutmare Warning: May cause customers to stare into the jar searching for hidden treasure.
The Origin: Most spicy peanut butters just bring heat. I wanted something smoky, sweet, and sinister that slowly creeps up on you.
Nutmare Warning: If your ears start smoking, that’s normal.
8oz: $13.99
16oz: $17.99
8oz: $13.99
16oz: $17.99
Spooky Cookie
The Origin: One night I wanted something different from the usual chocolate and honey flavors. I started thinking about those late-night cookie cravings, so I blended the taste of sweet cookies into fresh peanut butter. The result was Spooky Cookie—a flavor that tastes like a haunted bakery after dark.
Nutmare Warning: Do not leave unattended near milk. The cookies may start calling your name.
8oz: $14.99
16oz: $19.99
Ghostly Chill
The Origin: I wanted a flavor that felt like a haunted ice cream shop at midnight. Mint and chocolate seemed like the perfect combination for a chilling Nutmare experience.
Nutmare Warning: Side effects may include freezing in place while staring into the jar.
8oz: $14.99
16oz: $19.99
Batter Splatter
The Origin: I’ve been obsessed with brownies since I was a kid. While creating new Nutmare flavors, I wanted something that tasted like licking brownie batter straight from the bowl. After a lot of testing, Batter Splatter was born.
Nutmare Warning: May result in customers hiding jars from family members.
8oz: $14.99
16oz: $19.99
Get in Touch with the Nightmare
HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT OUR HAUNTING FLAVORS, INGREDIENTS, SHIPPING, OR CUSTOM ORDERS? SEND US A MESSAGE BELOW AND WE'LL GET BACK TO YOU AS SOON AS WE CAN